Aller au contenu principal
LaboGeek

ASUS ProArt P16 OLED vs MacBook Air M4 15 pouces vs ThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 12 : comparatif IA

Comparatif : ASUS ProArt P16 OLED vs MacBook Air M4 15" vs ThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 12 Le **MacBook Air M4 15"** remporte ce comparatif grâce à son excellent équilibre entre performances, autonomie (18h) et prix attractif (1 249 €). L'ASUS ProArt P16 OLED excelle pour les créatifs avec son écran 4K et sa RTX 4060, mais son prix élevé limite son attrait.

Notre verdict : ASUS ProArt P16 OLED

ASUS ProArt P16 OLED

Asus

Points forts

  • Écran OLED 16" 4K 3840x2400
  • Gamut couleurs large, contraste profond
  • Wi-Fi 7 et Bluetooth 5.4
  • 2x USB-C, 2x USB-A, HDMI, SD card

Points faibles

  • Écran limité à 60 Hz
  • Luminosité faible près d'une fenêtre
  • Écran brillant, reflets gênants
  • Audio saturé à volume élevé

MacBook Air M4 15 pouces

Apple

Points forts

  • Puce M4 passively cooled très performante
  • Single-core 30-45% > concurrence
  • Écran IPS 532 nits, 100% DCI-P3
  • Autonomie 18h usage quotidien

Points faibles

  • Seulement 2 ports USB-C
  • Pas d'écran 120Hz ni anti-reflet
  • Surcoût RAM/SSD inchangé
  • Aucune option maintenance

ThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 12

Lenovo

Points forts

  • SSD rapide : 1 512 Mo/s en transfert
  • Écran OLED 2880x1800 120Hz HDR
  • Clavier 1,5mm de course, 104 mots/min
  • 116% sRGB, 82,1% DCI-P3

Points faibles

  • Écran glossy avec reflets visibles
  • HDR rend le contenu non-HDR terne
  • Luminosité 389 nits, sous le MacBook Air
  • Transcodage vidéo plus lent que rivaux

Comparatif détaillé

SpécificationASUS ProArt P16 OLEDMacBook Air M4 15 poucesThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 12
npuAMD XDNA NPU (50 TOPS)Intel NPU (11 TOPS)
ram32 Go LPDDR5X16 Go (configurable jusqu'à 32 Go)16 Go, 32 Go, 64 Go LPDDR5x
wifiWi-Fi 7Wi-Fi 6E (802.11ax)
poids1,85 kg1,51 kg1,08 kg
ports["1x Thunderbolt 4","1x USB-C 3.2 Gen2","2x USB-A 3.2 Gen2","1x HDMI 2.1","Lecteur carte SD"]["1x MagSafe 3","2x Thunderbolt 4 (USB-C)","Prise casque 3,5 mm"]
price2499.99 EUR1249.0 EUR2035.66 EUR
camera12 MP Center Stage avec Desk View
webcamMIPI 8 MP avec IR
hauteur1,15 cm
largeur34,04 cm
batterie90 Wh
couleurs["Nano Black"]["Minuit","Lumière stellaire","Argent","Bleu ciel"]["Noir profond"]
securiteIntel TDT, lecteur d'empreintes, reconnaissance faciale IR
stockage1 To PCIe Gen4 SSD256 Go à 2 To SSD256 Go, 512 Go, 1 To, 2 To PCIe Gen 4 NVMe
autonomie15h (OLED) à 18h (LCD)
bluetoothBluetooth 5.4Bluetooth 5.3
coeurs cpu10 cœurs (4 performance + 6 efficacité)
coeurs gpu10 cœurs
dimensions355 x 251 x 14,9 mm31,2 x 21,5 x 1,49 cm
luminosite600 nits (HDR)500 nits
processeurAMD Ryzen AI 9 HX 370Apple M4Intel Core Ultra 5/7/9 (vPro Evo)
profondeur23,76 cm
type ecranOLED tactileLiquid Retina IPS rétroéclairé LEDOLED ou IPS anti-reflets
connectivite2x Thunderbolt 4, 2x USB-A, HDMI 2.1, Wi-Fi 6E, Bluetooth 5.3, 4G/5G (option)
format ecran16:10
taille ecran16 pouces15,3 pouces14 pouces
autonomie webJusqu'à 15 heures
frequence max5,1 GHz
gamut couleur100% DCI-P3, 100% Adobe RGB
neural engine16 cœurs
systeme audio6 haut-parleurs avec Dolby Atmos
densite pixels224 ppi
affiliate links[{"id":106,"url":"https://www.boulanger.com/ref/1219096","price":2499.99,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"boulanger","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":104,"url":"https://amzn.to/3M96OfX","price":2699,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"amazon","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":105,"url":"https://www.fnac.com/PC-portable-Asus-ProArt-P16-90NB15K1-M002E0-16-Ecran-tactile-OLED-60Hz-AMD-Ryzen-AI-9-32-Go-RAM-1-To-SSD-Noir/a21813065/w-4","price":2799.99,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"fnac","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":108,"url":"https://www.cdiscount.com/informatique/ordinateurs-pc-portables/ordinateur-portable-asus-asus-proart-p16-oled/f-1070992-asu1721953032770.html","price":3035.99,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"cdiscount","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":110,"url":"https://amzn.to/4bIQWLt","price":3299.99,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"amazon","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":112,"url":"https://www.boulanger.com/ref/1225291","price":3899.99,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"boulanger","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":198,"url":"https://amzn.to/4koEm6d","price":4499,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"amazon","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":199,"url":"https://www.boulanger.com/ref/1227271","price":4799.99,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"boulanger","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null}][{"id":80,"url":"https://amzn.to/49P1MhK","price":1249,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"amazon","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":60,"url":"https://www.cdiscount.com/informatique/ordinateurs-pc-portables/apple-15-3-macbook-air-m4-2025-ram-16go-s/f-10709-mw1l3fna.html","price":1249,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"cdiscount","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":59,"url":"https://www.darty.com/nav/achat/informatique/macbook_imac_ipad/macbook/apple_mba15_m4_16_256_ls.html","price":1299,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"darty","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":58,"url":"https://www.boulanger.com/ref/1219137","price":1299,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"boulanger","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":57,"url":"https://www.fnac.com/Apple-MacBook-Air-15-256-Go-SSD-16-Go-RAM-Puce-M4-CPU-10-coeurs-GPU-10-coeurs-Minuit/a20980169/w-4","price":1299,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"fnac","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":65,"url":"https://www.cdiscount.com/informatique/ordinateurs-pc-portables/apple-15-3-macbook-air-m4-2025-ram-16go-s/f-10709-mc7c4fna.html","price":1449,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"cdiscount","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":63,"url":"https://www.boulanger.com/ref/1219138","price":1499,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"boulanger","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":61,"url":"https://amzn.to/45FPTYR","price":1499,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"amazon","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":62,"url":"https://www.fnac.com/Apple-MacBook-Air-15-512-Go-SSD-16-Go-RAM-Puce-M4-CPU-10-coeurs-GPU-10-coeurs-Minuit/a20980211/w-4","price":1549,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"fnac","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":64,"url":"https://www.darty.com/nav/achat/informatique/macbook_imac_ipad/macbook/apple_mba15_m4_16_512_ar.html","price":1549,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"darty","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":66,"url":"https://amzn.to/3M9iTSh","price":1749,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"amazon","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":67,"url":"https://www.fnac.com/Apple-MacBook-Air-15-512-Go-SSD-24-Go-RAM-Puce-M4-CPU-10-coeurs-GPU-10-coeurs-Lumiere-Stellaire/a20980249/w-4","price":1799,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"fnac","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":68,"url":"https://www.boulanger.com/ref/1219088","price":1799,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"boulanger","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":69,"url":"https://www.darty.com/nav/achat/informatique/macbook_imac_ipad/macbook/apple_mba15_m4_24_512_ar.html","price":null,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"darty","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null}][{"id":206,"url":"https://amzn.to/4rH9rEY","price":2035.66,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"amazon","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null},{"id":13,"url":"https://amzn.to/4qkmH0Z","price":2088.266,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"amazon","availability":"in_stock","discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":0},{"id":207,"url":"https://amzn.to/4a6z9g9","price":2795.19,"currency":"EUR","is_primary":false,"marketplace":"amazon","availability":null,"discount_text":null,"discount_percentage":null}]
autonomie videoJusqu'à 18 heures
carte graphiqueNVIDIA GeForce RTX 4060 8 Go GDDR6
fonctionnalites["ASUS DialPad","Copilot+ PC"]
resolution ecran3840 x 2400 (4K)2880 x 1864 pixels2880 x 1800 (OLED) ou 1920 x 1200 (IPS)
resolution video1080p HD
capacite batterie66,5 Wh
coeurs processeur12 cœurs, 24 threads
precision couleurDelta E < 1
certification ecranPantone Validated, VESA DisplayHDR True Black 500
systeme exploitationWindows 11Windows 11 Pro
taux rafraichissement60 Hz120 Hz
bande passante memoire120 Go/s

Comparer d'autres produits

Lancez votre propre comparatif IA en sélectionnant 2 à 4 produits high-tech.

Ouvrir le comparateur →